If the handle fits, which it does, buy it. I am entirely pleased with the small handle that was provided. It is rated a grade 2 and I do not know why. To my eye, it is "choice". I did need to do some minor and expected filing and sanding to compliment the overall fit and make it close to perfect. Any shortfall is mine. I was surprised to find that the product is available. I am very pleased with the experience and quality of my purchase. I have some other period tools in need of good handles, including a very large circus stake sledge hammer. I have been unable to secure anything that is a fit. I believe there is one offered with dimensions that will be ideal. I will be anxious to find out.
![](http://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://beaver-tooth.com/products/copy-of-18-u-s-army-pick-replacment-handle-american-hickory&description=18"%20U.%20S.%20Army%20Pick%20Replacment%20Handle%20#2%20Grade&media=//beaver-tooth.com/cdn/shop/products/pick-18-u-s-army-pick-replacment-handle-2-grade-1_1024x1024.jpg?v=1525293221 "Pin It")
