I needed a new haft for a vintage Pulaski I've cleaned up for use around the property. I had heard good things and decided on Beaver Tooth for my purchase. I will say that the haft that was shipped to me was one of the cleanest grain white softwood hafts I had ever seen. I was so impressed I ordered 2 more handles for my felling axe and splitting maul.
My only complaint is I am spoiled by Amazon and two day shipping. Shipping from this seller seems to take close to a month to where I live in OH. That being said, If you don't need a new handle today, the quality is (subjectively) worth the wait.