I purchased these to replace the handles on my scoop shovels even though they were not necessarily designed for that; however they adapted very well and fit in to the neck just fine.
Haven't put them on yet but they look sturdy and perfect. (And made in the USA)
I do wish it came with the appropriate rivots. Or at least, what to look for at the hardware store. I did not want to use screws, or nut and bolt, but found something out hope will last. A little info sheet about what I should and should not put in the wood to make it last would be helpful. I like fixing instead of replacing.
We list what is included with each item. As for the items you mentioned all will work about the same it just comes down to how you want it look.
I guess I'm old school because I hate to throw anything away when it is still usable. So, I am replacing several broken handles and the products from Beaver-Tooth Handle Co. are excellent...maybe better that the original.
A Real Pleasure To Deal With This Seller Makes Outstanding Handles It The 3rd One I Bought, Perfect Fit On All Three Of Them (Axe, Maul & Shovel) And Very Happy With Them 5 Stars All The Way